4 year old boy was sentenced to life in prison for murder ‘by mistake’

Ahmed Mansour Karni was convicted and sentenced of participating in deadly riots which it’s said was committed in 2014 – when he was just two


A four-year-old boy was sentenced to life in prison after being found guilty on a murder charge by ‘mistake’, authorities in Egypt have reportedly claimed.

Ahmed Mansour Karni was convicted and sentenced of participating in deadly riotswhich it’s said was committed two years ago – when he was just two-years-old – last week.

The court in Western Cairo heard the case of Karni, who was listed as “wanted” formurder , disturbance of the peace and damaging state property.

But military spokesman Col. Mohammad Samir admitted today that the ruling had been an error.

The mix up was because the boy’s name is similar to a 16-year-old who should have received the sentence, according to the BBC.

One NewsAhmed Mansour Qurani Ali, 4, mistakenly sentenced to life for murder
Accused: Ahmed Mansour Qurani Ali, 4, was mistakenly sentenced to life for murder

Writing in a Facebook post Col. Samir said that Ahmed Mansour Qurani Sharara was the suspect they had intended to charge.

It is not clear what will happen to the teenager.

Defence lawyer Faisal a-Sayd said at the time that he believed the judge did not read the case.


“The child Ahmed Mansour Karni’s birth certificate was presented after state security forces added his name to the list of accused, but then the case was transferred to themilitary court and the child was sentenced in absentia in an ensuing court hearing,” he told The Jerusalem Post .

Read more: Controversy as boy aged 4 is sentenced to life in prison for murder when he was just 2

Lawyer Mohammed Abu Hurira said the case proved “there is no justice in Egypt… [It] is ruled by a bunch of lunatics.”

The indictment stated the charges in full as four counts of murder, eight counts of attempted murder, vandalising property belonging to the Egyptian Health Administration in his home province of el-Fayoum, threatening soldiers and police officers and damaging vehicles belonging to security forces.

Backlash: The ruling in Egypt has faced criticism with people questioning how it can happen

The ruling provoked backlash online with people condemning the sentencing.

TV Technologies wrote: “Think perhaps child bears similar name of older relative?”

Amy Hawthorne added: “It is possible given reports of recent cases of judiciary sentencing people to death who were already dead.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *