Air hand dryers should be banned from hospital toilets because they spread more germs than disposable paper towels, scientists say. Following a study carried out in three hospitals, it was revealed that using paper towels significantly reduces the risk of germs being spread among sick patients.
Surprisingly, high levels of dangerous bacteria that causes blood poisoning, pneumonia and gastroenteritis existed when dryers were used.
Writing in the Journal of Hospital Infection, researchers argued that official guidance about how to prevent bacterial contamination in hospital buildings needs to be strengthened. Scientists said the problem lies in people not washing their hands properly – meaning microbes get blown off by jet air dryers and spread around the room.
They said official Department of Health guidance is that air dryers can be placed in toilets in the public areas of a hospital, but not in clinical areas. However, this is not because of the risks they pose for cross-contamination, but because they are noisy.
Mark Wilcox, an expert in medical microbiology at the University of Leeds who supervised the international study, said that given the new evidence, the guidance needs to focus on the infection risks. Professor Wilcox said: ‘The problem starts because some people do not wash their hands properly. When people use a jet air dryer, the microbes get blown off and spread around the toilet room.
‘In effect, the dryer creates an aerosol that contaminates the toilet room, including the dryer itself and potentially the sinks, floor and other surfaces, depending on the dryer design and where it is sited. ‘If people touch those surfaces, they risk becoming contaminated by bacteria or viruses.
Jet air dryers often rely on no-touch technology to initiate hand drying. However, paper towels absorb the water and microbes left on the hands and if they are disposed of properly, there is less potential for cross-contamination.’
The study looked at bacterial spread in a real world setting, in two toilets in each of three hospitals, which were in the UK, France and Italy. Each of the toilets had paper towel dispensers and jet air dryers, but only one of these was in use on any given day. On each day, over 12 weeks, levels of bacterial contamination in the toilets were measured, allowing comparisons to be made when either paper towels or jet air dryers were in use. Samples were taken from the floors, air and surfaces in each of the toilets.
The main target bacteria were Enterobacteria including Escherichia coli or E.coli, which cause a wide range of infections including gastroenteritis, pneumonia and septicaemia, and enterococci – bacteria that can cause difficulty when treating infections.
They also looked for Staphylococcus aureus, which is responsible for a range of conditions, from minor skin and wound infections to life-threatening septicaemia. Across the three hospitals, bacterial counts were significantly higher in the toilets on the days that jet air dryers were in use.
In Leeds and Paris, at least five times more bacteria were recovered from the floors when jet-air dryers were in use, compared with paper towels. In Leeds, Staphylococcus aureus (including MRSA) was found three times more often and in higher amounts on the surface of the jet air dryers compared with the paper towel dispensers.
Significantly more enterococci and multi-drug resistant bacteria were recovered from either the floors or dust in the toilets when the jet air dryers rather than paper towels were in use. In Italy, researchers found significantly fewer bacteria on the surface of paper towel dispensers compared with the jet air dryers, although no significant difference on the floors. Prof Wilcox added: ‘We found multiple examples of greater bacterial contamination on surfaces, including by fecal and antibiotic-resistant bacteria, when jet air dryers rather than paper towels were in use.
‘Choice of hand drying method affects how likely microbes can spread, and so possibly the risk of infection.’ The study is the largest of its type to investigate whether the way people dry their hands has an impact on the spread of bacteria.